Cairns & Company/Thoughts
No. 030 25 Oct 2026

A stranger wants to buy your company: how to tell a serious approach from a fishing trip

M&AExitsConsumer Health

Most owners of a good natural health, ingredient or skincare business will, sooner or later, receive an email or a call from someone they do not know who says they are “interested in the company”. The message is often flattering and nearly always vague. It leaves the owner with a question they are poorly placed to answer: is this a real buyer or someone collecting information?

The cost of getting it wrong runs both ways. Treat a serious acquirer carelessly and you lose the one buyer who had already done the homework. Treat a fishing trip seriously and you hand a competitor your numbers, unsettle your team and spend a month on a conversation with no end. A few simple tests separate the two, and they can be applied before anything is shared.

The first test: who is asking, and with what authority. A serious approach comes from someone who can decide, or who can put a decision-maker in the room. A corporate development head, a fund principal or a founder-led acquirer will say so, and can describe how their organisation approves a purchase. An approach from a junior analyst, a generic “partnerships” address or an intermediary who will not name the principal tells you the buyer is exploring rather than hunting. That is not disqualifying, but it sets the pace: nothing material will happen quickly.

The second test: can they say why you. The approaches that matter are specific. They name what the buyer lacks and why your business closes that gap: a validated ingredient they would otherwise take years to develop, registrations in a market they want to enter, a channel or a customer base they cannot build quickly. If the message could have been sent to any company in your category, it probably was. A buyer who has done the work will tell you in two sentences what they would do with the business, and that they can explain it at all is the best early sign of seriousness.

A serious buyer can tell you in two sentences why your business and what they would do with it. A fishing trip cannot.

The third test: who goes first. A genuine acquirer will accept being the one to show their hand. They will disclose who they are, what they own and what sort of transaction they have in mind before asking you for anything of substance. A fishing trip reverses the order. It asks for revenue, margins, customer lists and supplier names in exchange for a promise of interest. Share only what you would be content to see in front of a competitor, and nothing detailed until a confidentiality agreement is signed and you have checked who stands behind the name. A competitor will often use a third party for exactly this reason.

The fourth test: do they know the people and the process. A buyer who has made acquisitions in this sector will talk comfortably about registrations, claims substantiation, contract manufacture and the realities of selling through pharmacy, grocery and export channels. One who has not will talk in generalities. In the New Zealand and Australian market it also matters whether they understand how small the world is. A buyer who treats discretion as an afterthought, copies several people into early messages or asks you to hold conversations on open channels, is telling you how they will behave when it matters.

How to respond without committing. You do not owe a reply on the buyer's timetable, and you should resist the urge to answer with either enthusiasm or a refusal. A short, courteous reply is enough: acknowledge the approach, say you are not currently running a process, and ask three things. Who is the principal behind the enquiry? What is the strategic reason for the interest? And what would they need from you to take a first conversation further? The quality of the answers will tell you far more than the original message did. Do not name a price. The first number said aloud becomes the anchor for everything after it, and the owner who has not yet established what the business is worth to a range of buyers is poorly placed to set it.

Know your own answer before you reply. The approach that tests owners is the good one, from a credible buyer, at a moment when they had not thought about selling. Without a view of what they would want from a sale, the founder either dismisses an opportunity or is carried along by it. It helps to have settled in advance three things: roughly what the business is worth to different types of buyer, what you would want from a deal beyond price, and whether you would rather shape your own process than react to a buyer's. We have written elsewhere about the first forty-eight hours after an offer, and most of it applies here too. The difference is that an approach gives you more time than an offer, and the best use of it is to prepare.

What a good approach deserves. If the buyer passes the tests, treat them well even if you are not ready. The best acquirers think in years. A courteous no today, with an honest indication of when you might look again, is often how the strongest transactions begin. Founders sometimes underestimate how rarely a prepared buyer with real strategic reasons turns up, and how much more it matters to be remembered as an easy and credible person to deal with than to have extracted a quick answer.

Why we write about this. We act for owners and for acquirers, and from both sides the pattern is the same. Good approaches are mishandled because the owner has no framework for judging them, and poor ones consume time because there was no easy way to say no. A short set of tests, applied calmly, fixes most of it. For acquirers the lesson is the mirror image: the approach that works is specific, senior, unhurried and honest about who is behind it, as we described in our note on building a proprietary pipeline.

If you have received an approach and are unsure how to read it, or you are acquiring and want it to land well, we are glad to talk in confidence. You can also have these notes sent to you by email.

More notes on deals, capital and owner-led businesses on the Thoughts page, or have them sent to you by email.